Magicians Richard Turner, Young & Strange, Kayla Drescher, and Mike Super try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
Magicians Xavier Mortimer, Fielding West, Caleb Wiles, and Kevin Hall the Magic Maniac try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
Magicians Vitaly Beckman, Simon Coronel, Mac King, and Kevin Viner try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
Magicians Elliot Zimet, Paul Gertner, Matthew Disero, and Rokas try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
Magicians Alex Ramon, Greg Frewin, Vinny Grosso, and Arthur Trace try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
Magicians David & Leeman, Jibrizy, Rick Maisel, and Felix Bodden try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
Magicians Robert Ramirez, Dominik, Joel Ward, and Mahdi Gilbert try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks.
Magicians Brett Loudermilk, Dan Harlan, Ryan Joyce, and Kyle Eschen try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks. Actor Jesse Eisenberg performs a trick with Penn & Teller.
Magicians Shawn Farquhar, Michael Kent, Nathan Burton, and Nathan Coe Marsh try to fool the veteran duo with their tricks. Alyson Hannigan serves as host.
